Why we chose not to use a script or have dialogue

Whilst we were preparing our thriller opening, we had to decide if we were firstly going to use a script and secondly use any background noises from recording.

This is an example of a thriller opening that has dialogue/a script involved, and in my opinion although the thriller itself was well made and has a good story, the speaking sounded very scripted and unrealistic.

 

This second video is an example of an A grade thriller opening that does not have a script or any speaking involved, this makes the thriller sound much better with just edited sound and music involved, this also allows the editer to add extra music into it to make the video intense, and not keep it simple to allow the dialogue to take place.

 
Overall I think it would be much better if we did not use a script in our thriller as it could sound very bad and unprofessional, also at our location there is a lot of background noises that are very loud and irritating even when we arent filming, for example a train goes by our location every few minutes and makes a lot of noise, and also dog walkers sometimes walk by and the dogs could bark and ruin the scene, so ideally, we would be much better off if we did not include any background noise or speaking as it would allow us to take advantage of any music or sound effects we want to use while not focusing on developing the dialougue.